Playback: Streaming your Mac to a PS3 or Xbox 360

by Smoking Apples

Playback: Streaming your Mac to a PS3 or Xbox 360

by Smoking Apples on November 3, 2009

Post image for Playback: Streaming your Mac to a PS3 or Xbox 360

playback-header

[tweetmeme] I’ve had the PS3 for about two years now, but more than games, I’ve been watching movies on it. The PS3 supports DivX/MPEG-4 as well as Windows Media playback, so if you’ve got it hooked up to a nice big TV, there’s no reason to continue watching movies on your Mac.

However, in most scenarios, your Mac is the central repository for all your downloaded media. Movies, music and photos that you may download are either stored on your Mac HD or an external hard drive. Getting these to play directly on your TV would usually involve connecting the external hard drive to the TV/DVD player or the PS3 and playing them them off the drive.

But that’s so 2005. The PS3 has Wi-Fi. Your Mac has Wi-Fi. Why do you still have wires going into your media player?

uPnP

Enter uPnP. Universal Plug and Play (uPnP for short) is a set of protocols that allow devices to interact with each other over a network without requiring any configuration or software drivers. A subset of this standard–and the one we’re more interested in–is called uPnP AV or DLNA (Digital Living Network Alliance), which allows for devices called media servers to stream content over the network to uPnP clients.

The PS3 is a uPnP client that can pull media from a server and play it back on your TV wirelessly. If you’re using Windows Vista or higher, you can enable Media Sharing in Windows Media Player 11, which will make your PC act as a DLNA media server. If you’re running Mac OS X, there’s no similar, built-in functionality. And if you’re using Mac OS 9, you really need to go and get a new Mac.

Playback

To fill that void in Mac OS X, there’s YazSoft’s Playback. It’s a very, very simple application that takes a list of folders with music, movies and photos and makes your Mac behave as a DLNA media server. One of the few things I missed from my switch to Mac from Windows was the ability to wirelessly play movies from my computer on my PS3 and Playback is exactly what I was looking for.

playback-menu

When I said ‘simple’, I really meant it. I can’t stress how easy Playback is to set up and use. You start the app. You pick the folders with your media. You click the “Start” button. And then you go sit on the couch with the PS3 controller. In fact, it can take longer to set up Media Sharing in Windows Media Player 11 and if it suddenly stops working (for e.g.. if your PS3 can’t find the media server or any content in it), it’s quite a pain to try and figure out what’s going wrong and where. Playback gets full points on ease of use.

In spite of being so simple, Playback doesn’t compromise on functionality. You can share movies, music pictures, or just one of these items (via tick boxes on the main screen). You can add multiple folder locations from all attached storage devices or you can just share your iTunes and iPhoto content.

Note that even though movies in your iTunes library can be streamed by Playback, DRM-protected content such as store purchases are not streamable. This is understandable on part of the app, but might be a hindrance for those who depend on the iTunes Store for their content (AppleTV would be a much better solution for those).

For the more advanced and/or security-conscious users, you can also limit your media server bandwidth and control which devices can access the content on your media server. Typically, you won’t need this in a home environment, but if you’ve got a PS3 in the office, well, you’re lucky in more ways than one.

PS3-playback-browsing
What it looks like on the PS3

The cherry on top is Growl notification support. Everytime a new client connects to your server and/or starts playing movies or music, Playback growls at you.

Performance

You can watch most movies hiccup-free, so long as they’re not several gigabytes in size. Single or double CD movies work fine, but movies over that can stutter a bit. The Macs support 802.11n, but the PS3 doesn’t and that’s the problem.

Sometimes, even with basic ~700MB movies, you may encounter a few pauses and stutters, but this isn’t Playback’s problem. I noticed this behavior with Windows too. This typically is heightened if you’re streaming media from an external hard drive. I have a 1TB USB hard drive which contains most of my movies and music, so I occasionally run into this problem, but I’ve learnt to ignore it. A few breaks in a movie are good anyway!

Price and Conclusion

Playback costs just $15. I think it’s excellent value for money from a product that does what it does, is so easy to use and so flexible. If you’ve got a uPnP AV/DLNA compliant device such as the PS3 or Xbox360[1. The author did not test this app on an Xbox360, I added that on the assumption that it should work, since the product page says so. - Ed] and a stash of movies and music on your Mac (or an external hard drive), there’s no reason to not buy this.

If you’re not convinced, download the trial copy of Playback and give it a shot. I’m sure you’ll like it.

Reviewed version: 1.1
Pros: Easy to set up and use, flexible, cheap
Cons: Unable to play DRM-protected content
Rating: 4/5

Alternatives

Before I tried Playback, I tried using Plex (formerly XBMC) and Boxee. Both were very unreliable and seemed to crash randomly. In my configuration, I was unable to get any movie to stream to the PS3 using either of these. It was a scratch I couldn’t itch. It didn’t take me more than 5 minutes to start watching the movie after installing Playback. It was so relieving.

However, Boxee and Plex are free and are full-fledged media center applications with a lot more functionality, so the comparison is not entirely fair.

Aalaap Ghag cannot be described in a few lines across the bottom of this review. In fact, this PHP coding, Twitter addicted, Samosa Pav eating guy has got more than fifteen lines of description across his homepage.

{ 11 comments… read them below or add one }

Matthew Rex Downham

This isn’t the first by any means. “Connect360″, “MediaLink” and “Rivet” have all done this task for a few years. I believe Playback is the cheapest of the group, but from what I can tell it doesn’t do anything new.

   

Manuel Fdez-Peix Perez

PS3 Media Server is a free, cross-platform DLNA compliant Upnp Media Server: http://code.google.com/p/ps3mediaserver/

   

Akzel

Now, really, PS3 Media Server owns them all… It’s FREE and it also streams stuff like MKV movies that are not allowed to be streamed by Rivet, et al.

Shame on the advertisement-like post. Next time be clear, please put a disclaimer on top and I won’t have to waste my time with a “review”…

   

Aalaap Ghag

I just bought an Xbox 360 on the weekend and tried this thing out and it works equally perfectly awesomely smokingly well!!!

   

timbo

I use Rivet with a 360. Love it.

however, how can I play .mkv formats?!

   

FactRobot

I’d have to agree with the votes for PS3 Media Server. The fact that it’s free and can stream MKV should crown it king.

   

Anotherspot

Over the years I have used Connect360, Rivet and a trial of Playback.
Out of those I preferred Rivet.

Recently I have really enjoyed “PS3 Media Server” price is too hard to refuse, and with built-in transcoding of other formats provides access to even more media than ever before.

I have found the stability of PS3 Media Server my only reason to fall back to using Rivet.

   

g7whatever

I bought and use Rivet – not knowing that Rivet will not play the new supposedly DRM “free” music from itunes.

Tested Connect360 – it will at least transcode the “protected” AAC from itunes to mp3 so i can truly listen to my whole library – so I may buy this because of how many songs I have purchased from itunes thinking that they would play on my xbox- sense the are DRM free NOT.

Playback like Rivet should be more clear – in that it can not clearly playback ALL of you media from you mac – only some, but I guess that would not be a great sales line. “Stream most of, or some of you media from your mac to….”

   

Pollo Loco

Im using MediaLink 2.0 beta and its a good choice too, I tried all of the above and ended with MediaLink. Plex did work for me, but since it uses more CPU resources and crashes sometimes I´ll keep using this one.

PS: Im also using file sharing (SMB) on OSX to stream to boxee on other PCs/Macs in the house,…

   

Janirorial Services

I am using playback and connect 360 to stream from a ppc mac connected to a 1 TB WD external hardrive to an Xbox 360 via wifi. Connect 360 seems to index a bit quicker but playback has better indexing function. I have used both for hd movies and music. So far I prefer playback. I can also grab content of my mac from a few different iphone apps via playback.

   

Darren

Does playback able to stream to Sony Blu-ray players? If not, that would be great to add in the near future.

   

Leave a Comment

We'd love it if you would add your opinion to the article or discussion, whether positive or negative. We reserve the right to moderate comments at our discretion.

Previous post:

Next post: