Notebook 3.0, the Mac alternative to Microsoft OneNote

by Milind Alvares on June 25, 2009

Post image for Notebook 3.0, the Mac alternative to Microsoft OneNote

notebook-imgI’ve heard this whine far too many times. Where’s the OneNote alternative for the Mac? Seems like everyone on the PC had been using OneNote and were shocked to find that Office for Mac does not come with OneNote. I had never used OneNote for more than 15 seconds when I did use Windows, so had to find out what OneNote stood for in the first place.

It’s basically a swiss army knife of digital notebooks. In brief, here’s how it works. There’s tabs for separate ‘notebooks’ on the left side, such as for ‘personal’, ‘work’, etc. Each notebook has multiple pages, separated at the top by tabs (much like you would in a business notebook). Within these tabs are several notebook pages, which are separated by tabs on the right side. All of these of course serve a separate purpose, and the whole thing executes pretty nicely. On the notebook page itself, you can add text, copy and paste HTML and images, and it can even extract text from images (or so it says). You can even use a pen tablet to write on the notebook, or use the mouse to draw shapes like boxes and arrows. There’s system-wide shortcuts for adding stuff to the notebook, and there’s even a temporary area for dumping stuff. So that’s OneNote 2007 for the PC, and I’m looking to find something similar on the Mac.

Circus Ponies’ Notebook 3.0

This is the first app that comes in mind when looking for a OneNote alternative. While similar in the end it’s trying to acheive, Notebook is in many ways different from OneNote. So let’s see how it works.

notebook-30

On first launch, you’re presented with a ‘Starting Point’ screen, which brings up a pre-packaged notebook geared for a college student, researcher, planning projects, or just use it like a place to stuff in all your junk. You can of course also start with a blank notebook, which is what I did.

Notebook has a very minimal user interface, especially when compared with the clutter that comes with OneNote. It’s a floating virtual notebook on your screen, taking up only the space required by a single sheet of ruled paper. Unlike OneNote’s three sided tabby interface, Notebook has tabs tucked on only one side. However, they’re more than just skin deep as we’ll see later.

Adding Content

So how do you add content to your notebook? Simply double click to create a new text field. You can enter text, drag in text, drag in files, draw shapes using the shape tools. The shapes you draw are also sticky, so arrows snap to edges when you’re creating something like a flow chart. One of the most interesting ways of adding content, especially stuff you want to shove in without thought, is to add a clipping service. Take any notebook page, add a title ‘Links’, and ‘Add a Clipping Service’. Now in virtually any application, you can select something, go to the App Menu » Service » Notebook » and add to “Links” or whatever your title may have been. If you find that a little tedious, remember you can add any shortcut to that menu item.

notebook-links

Organisation of Tabs

Notebook has a beautiful organisational structure. The tab at the top is “Contents”. It will list out your ‘Dividers’ as well as the Multidex. Dividers are to be thought of like those thick plastic sheets between a notebook with a tab sticking out. You can add as many dividers as you want from the contents page. Click on a divider, and you’re presented with an organised list of ‘topics’. These are your notebook page titles. Double click on the page title to go into that page.

At the bottom lies the Multidex. This is sort of the aggregator of all things. It will automatically gather Text, Attachments, Numbers, Capitalized words, and much more. Double click into it and you’re presented with a traditional index of items.

multidex-notebook

When it comes to the pages themselves, you have different styles like ledger, steno, writing, and even special ones like “Cornell Page” which I remember from back in school.

Organisation of Data

Data is organised into units which I think are referred to as ‘cells’. Any bit of data will be tied to a blue dot at the margin. You can move this blue dot around, and add actions to it. You can add a check box, due date, add sub items for outlining, and it displays certain status information in the margin to the left.

This cell is the foundation as to how Notebook works. When you search for something using the global search (which is very efficient), it will narrow down results and present you with information in units. You can open units in new windows, cut them up, as well as create links to cells across different dividers.

Gripes

As much as I liked Notebook, sometimes it’s a little frustrating. Those ‘cells’ are not as free floating as I’d like them to be, so spatially arranging your notebook is not the most convenient thing to do. Perhaps there’s a setting in there I’m not aware of. Second, the clipping service should have automatically linked it to the web page or file I’m clipping that info from. So I could easy grab a paragraph of text from some place on the net and have the link ready and waiting whenever I need it.

Third, is drawing shapes is not the best of implementations. I’d prefer an annotation system like LittleSnapper. And lastly, I’d have liked if the app looked a little sleeker. The UI elements look a little dated, especially since the nature of the app would allow for so much improvement.

Packed with features

Notebook is filled to the brim with features, yet it presents everything in such a clean and organised user interface. I think I’ve gone through just 25% of what Notebook has to offer. You can record audio clippings directly from within the interface, snap pictures using the iSight camera, organise everything into keywords, and most importantly find information without a hassle.

I set out to find a bunch of OneNote alternatives for the Mac, but knew I had the app with Notebook. I should probably shut up about OneNote since I haven’t used it extensively, but in my limited use Notebook not only matches OneNote, it’s got a better user interface, better integration with the OS, comes with plentiful of features. A standard license of Notebook costs $50 while a student license comes at a subsidised $30. At either cost, if you constantly find yourself getting lost amidst your data, Notebook will set things right for you.

[Notebook img via Flickr]


Reader Comments

Notebook 3.0, the Mac alternative to Microsoft OneNote | Smoking … | Hipacopa
July 5, 2009 at 5:11 am

Reader Comments

duke June 25, 2009 at 9:42 pm

Word for Mac has a notebook feature that is not found in the PC version. I use that as a free alternative.

   

brnmbrns June 25, 2009 at 10:17 pm twitter.com/brianxburns

@duke How is that a FREE alternative?
Pirated?

   

Jim June 25, 2009 at 10:42 pm thegraphicmac.com

1 word: EVERNOTE!

   

Alan Williams June 25, 2009 at 10:54 pm twitter.com/alanwill

I agree with Jim, check out Evernote. I’m a past user if Notebook 3 and haven’t looked back since checking out Evernote.

   

Edward Ayres June 25, 2009 at 11:17 pm edayrescomedy.com

I can’t think of a more useless application. It’s only purpose is a central storage area for things you want to remember and there are number of ways to create that without buying additional software. The video tutorials on the site are from employees grasping at straws trying to justify the reason for this product to exist. One person says it saves him the trouble of sending himself e-mails. Well, if you have to send the reminder to your Evernote account why just send yourself the email? There are numerous examples of profit-motivated justifications for using this service in their tutorials section but that doesn’t change the fact that this software and storage service can done elsewhere for free.

   

ookami June 25, 2009 at 11:28 pm

yep, I have been using Evernote since …forever, and there still isn’t really an alternative for me.
I especially like the integration with my iphone.

I must say though, that I miss the ability to arrange my text and images and draw lines and the like. As it where a mind mapping app. that is a feature that I miss from my time with OneNote.

Also OneNote’s ability to have a shared note-taking project with friends during a lecture was “gold”
(Basically allowing people at the lecture add notes to the same project live, and instantly see their changes.)

But for now, Evernote will do :)

   

duke June 25, 2009 at 11:31 pm

@brnmbrns - you’re right. I already have office for mac. Made a bad assumption that most people looking for One Note would have office for mac already.

   

Steve June 26, 2009 at 1:16 am

NoteTaker (aquaminds.com) is a close twin of NoteBook, not surprising, since they originated from the same product. The only substantive advantage of NB over NT I’ve seen is that in NB, one can “tear out” a page and so work with two different pages atg one time.

I manage large projects by linking project files, databases, and programs into a notebook, so linking is important to me. NoteBooks linking abilities are quite crude compared to those of NoteTaker.. To link (or to attach into a NT package, you can copy (ctrl-c) one or more files in the finder and paste them (ctrl-v) into a page. The only approach NoteBook offered the last time I looked was dragging and dropping. In NT one can mix text and linked files on the same line, handy for annotating linked files; This isn’t possible with NB. With NT it is easy to move links anyplace on a page; it isn’t easy with NB. In trials, I found myself more productive with NT (but wished for the “tear off” feature.

One other substantive advantage of NT is that notebooks can be shared and edited collaboratively. To do this, one must purchase the NoteShare software that Aquaminds sells. This has made NT a favorite for teachers. Aquaminds is also working on extending NT to the Windows environment.. Already it is possible to edit web notebooks in a browser on any platform.

So both are good products.

   

ookami June 26, 2009 at 12:46 pm

@Steve

Been checking out NoteTaker, and it seems close to what I have been looking for. Thanks for the input. :)
But as a student, I have to say its very pricy. And it would have been great if there were an integration with the Iphone. oh well, I think I will play around with the 30 day trial and see if I can get used to it.

cheers.

   

john June 26, 2009 at 2:04 pm

I use xPad. Fulfils prettu much the same function but is Freeware.

   

Viswakarma June 26, 2009 at 7:14 pm

SubEthaEdit is an application that might be of interest to the users of NoteTaker, Evernote, Notebook etc. —

http://www.codingmonkeys.de/subethaedit/

   

DRayMIS June 26, 2009 at 10:18 pm

I haven’t used Evernote is a couple of years; does it now offer the ability to due tabs like Notebook or create different entries like Journler, or does it still use the ‘endless tape’ idea?

   

Puneet June 27, 2009 at 10:15 pm ipuneet.posterous.com

Milind Thanks for the review …like someone mentioned in comments i too Find Evernote More convenient, it may not be onenote alternative in True sense but it does the job its great Specially with its Sync Feature & iphone app

   

Jumpq January 19, 2010 at 2:21 am

NB 3.0 is limited and frustrating but pretty. Aquaminds is more flexible but not as cute. I wielded through all the organizers for quiet sometime I dumped NB and Aquamind. Evernote is only used to sync temporary info to my iphone, MacBook, MacMini and iMac . So what am I using in my working envirnonment : ONENOTE . Can’t compare with all the previous apps put together. Sorry folks. As much as I love the MAC . There is no OneNote alternative . It took over six months for Circus Pony to implement a table feature when it was advertised in 3.0 release. Aquamind development is also slow since they develop incrementally , they never release a major upgrade. CP 3.0 is really a 2.5 since it did not have ‘major’ feature upgrades . CP does not have a notebook library drawer, global search across notebooks and is frustrating at times , but its cute to open up and think of what it could have been , if both Aquamind and CP never went their separate ways . OneNote 2010 has even more features that makes it light years ahead !!

   

BethK January 30, 2010 at 2:59 am

I am using an Interwrite tablet display on a Windows 7 PC while teaching. That software can’t seem to save files so that they can be imported or exported to the Mac version of their software. Plus it isn’t being as smooth as it was with Windows XP.

So I’m switching to using Microsoft OneNote for class lectures. I can write on the display, convert handwriting to text, put pictures where I want, draw lines connecting this and that, … But I’d like to export in an editable form as well as be able to import files created in a similar app on Mac.

I’m looking for interoperability. I have Word 2004 for Mac, but it won’t open the OneNote files. Notebook doesn’t look like it will do it either. So I’ll keep looking.

   

Valery January 31, 2010 at 12:24 am

I have found free alternative to Onenote - Pinoteo (www.pinoteo.com)
It’s a digital board for creating and saving notes. Now there is only version for Windows, but
very soon it’ll be version for Mac

   

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: