Camtasia for Mac: Professional Screen Recording made easy

by Milind Alvares on August 26, 2009

Post image for Camtasia for Mac: Professional Screen Recording made easy

camtasia-for-mac-review

Screen Capture apps on the Mac are like the todo list apps of the iPhone. There’s just so many of them it’s hard to cover them all at once. However, now with the built in screen capture and editing functionality of QuickTime X in Snow Leopard, the basic apps will go obsolete clearing the market for the higher end tools.

When I first heard about Camtasia coming to the Mac, I was not impressed. Judging by the Windows screenshots I thought it would utterly fail on the Mac platform. Boy was I in for a pleasant surprise. I hereby pronounce Camtasia to be the current best screen capture application for the Mac. So how did I come to such a strong conclusion?

Camtasia 5

1-2-3-Go

Start Camtasia and you’re presented with an easy to use record palette. The Windows-ness of the developers can be seen here in terms of icon design, but we’ll ignore that for now. So by default it records your screen, but with a click you can make it record audio from a line-in or mic, the iSight or attached camera, and even the system audio. Camtasia records the full screen. So far so normal.

camtasia 6

Once you’re done recording however, the full interface presents itself. To the left is the library and effects. In the middle is the canvas. The right shows tool configurations. And at the bottom lies a standard timeline. The user interface reminds one of Screenflow, the current leader in screen capture for the Mac.

No more drone work

While the UI elements aren’t exactly ‘tasty’, the user interface has been made into a super easy to use drag and drop affair. Click the video effects, and hover over a thumbnail to see a preview of what it does. To apply it to a clip just drag it onto the timeline and you’re done. Camtasia makes it super easy to apply zooms, fades, and flips. I know how difficult it is to add a fade-out/fade-in effect for clips, and to have it done just by drag and drop is nothing short of amazing.

Camtasia
Those blue green blocks are fade-ins and outs, dropped in from the effects.

One of the most tedious tasks of adding effects, is panning from one window to the other. Camtasia has something called ‘SmartFocus’, which automatically detects mouse movements and adds these pans in between. Granted it doesn’t quite get the location right, but it at least sets you on the right track. You can then adjust the video, all of which can be acheived within a minute or two.

Jazz it up

Camtasia also comes with a bunch of effects that will help spice things up. You can choose from regular effects like colour adjustment, sepia tones and drop shadows to frame glow, reflection, and a beautifully done Window Spotlight. With the window spotlight effect applied, Camtasia blurs out the background and any other windows while focussing the frontmost window. The result is a much more focussed video while still keeping the desktop in perspective.

Camtasia 4
You can control the amount of blur, opacity, and even size up the focussed window.

Adjustments

On the right is an adjustment pane which allows you to control all of these effects. As you apply effects to your clip, they stack up along with their settings. To remove an effect just delete it from the stack. You can adjust nearly anything from the blur amount in window focus to the size and rotation of your canvas.

Camtasia 2

Make it fly

Camtasia comes with support for exporting to iTunes compatible video for use with the iPhone, AppleTV or computer playback. You can also directly export video to YouTube or Screencast.com, both of which are very handy additions indeed. And finally, for those wanting total control, you can use the advanced export to adjust codecs and compression to your hearts content.

Camtasia 2

I’ll be using it for sure


It took me five minutes to get familiar with the user interface, and produce a decent screencast at the end of it. I love the way it takes not more than two steps to apply crucial effects like zooming and panning, ‘skimming’ over library clips, and video effects are just icing on the cake. All through editing the UI acts just the way you wanted to. One feature worth the mention is ripple delete, which allows you to remove a clip as well as the space it occupies in your timeline. And lastly, if the app crashes, it’s nice to know that Camtasia had been saving your work all along and offers to recover it. This is my initial impression, as I haven’t had much time to go through the app for a considerable amount of time. I’m sure some niggles will show up, but at first run it’s proven itself.

Camtasia for Mac is completely different from the Camtasia Studio for Windows. The application looks and feels like a Mac application, is very stable, feature rich, and I’m happy to recommend it to anyone looking to create good screencasts. At $99 for a single user it’s worth it, but only for those who are serious about screen capture; the rest can use QuickTime X.

Reader Comments

5 hidden features in MacOSX Snow Leopard | MacFlaunt
August 27, 2009 at 11:15 pm
The Wait is Over: Camtasia for Mac! : E-merge-ENG Ed.
August 28, 2009 at 11:05 am
Presenting, they who make it happen… | Smoking Apples
October 18, 2009 at 8:25 pm
Screencast Software - MacTalk Forums
January 5, 2010 at 9:33 am

Reader Comments

Aaron Swindell August 27, 2009 at 12:07 am aaronworks

I don’t mean to burst your hyperbolic bubble for Camtasia:mac, but had you ever tried ScreenFlow? Camtasia:mac is basically ScreenFlow with the effects thrown in. Camtasia:mac premieres at $99, but will go up to $149 next year, while ScreenFlow has always been $99. Both are slick tools, however I think I’ll hold on to my money a bit longer and see what I can do with QuickTime X once it drops.

   

Mitchell Milliron August 27, 2009 at 12:40 am

Camtasia for Mac is a decent first effort, but in my trial I didn’t find any way to add mouse click highlighting. Also, there doesn’t appear to be any keyboard capture, so displaying user input must be done in post with text boxes. And finally, calling focus to the foreground window is a filter, which means it is applied to the entire clip. Sometimes one just wants to highlight the foreground window for a moment, but not the entire clip. As for the SmartFocus? Not that impressive, and really doesn’t save that much time if you need to tweak the focus points. I think ScreenFlow is still going to lead this category since they’ve got the jump on Camtasia.

   

Milind Alvares August 27, 2009 at 2:34 am soggysh.it

@Aaron: I have in fact been using Screenflow all along for creating the SA screencasts. I mentioned that Camtasia looks very familiar to Screenflow; perhaps someone borrowed from someone. However, ultimately I find Camtasia to be easier and more efficient.

@Mitchell:
- Agreed, mouse click, keyboard clicks and zoom ups are missing.
- For window focus, splitting a clip is as easy as Cmd+T.

The battle between Screenflow and Camtasia will be a close one. Screenflow 2 has been announced—set to release mid-september—and will bring in YouTube support, 2D and 3D clip transitions, and clip speed adjustments. I haven’t used Screenflow 2 so I can’t say how good it really is.

   

ookami August 27, 2009 at 4:41 am

ScreenFlow 2 ? uh uh! looking forward to that.
I have only been using ScreenFlow a little bit, but have been most impressed with its many features and ease of use.

Still a good write up, thanks :)

   

Eknath August 27, 2009 at 10:18 am eknathkadam.net

Hey….its a review of a screen cast software….where is the screen cast?

   

iamse7en August 27, 2009 at 10:38 am

I prefer Screenium. Sometimes I just want to record a PORTION of the screen. I couldn’t figure out how to do it with Screenflow, and with Screenium, it was SOO easy.

   

Milind Alvares August 27, 2009 at 11:23 am soggysh.it

@Iamse7en: You can’t grab just a portion of the screen with either Screenflow or Camtasia. You can of course just as well crop the video very easily once you’re done recorded. As I understand it, these apps grab the desktop in separate layers, unlike the lesser apps. This allows them to ignore static activity like the desktop wallpaper while focussing processing power on the active window. And most importantly, this allows them to have effects like window focus, and cursor effects.

Mitchell Milliron August 27, 2009 at 12:04 pm

@Milind Did some more playing tonight with Camtasia. As you mention, you can split clips and then add a filter to a smaller portion, but you still can’t ease in/out on let’s say, the Window Spotlight, using this technique.

I did go back and forth between Camtasia and ScreenFlow for some side by side testing. I do like the look and feel of Camtasia. The 3 panes and timeline work well. I’m not as familiar with Camtasia yet, but the editing process doesn’t feel as intuitive to me as Screenflow. I’d probably chock that up to inexperience though.

I don’t think the text tool is very good at this point. You have to add an additional library item to have a background for your text. Also, adding color to library items requires you add the item, then add the Colorize filter. I think they could just have the color in the inspector pane for the item and save the second step and hassle.

I did have Camtasia unexpectedly quit on me once, so that didn’t feel good. All in all, the interface is very good looking, but the feature set lacks some of the more useful tools I prefer in a screencast application.

   

Burke August 27, 2009 at 12:40 pm

Off topic, but does anyone know where I can find the wallpaper that’s in the screenshots embedded in the article? It’s really beautiful and would love to have it on my computer.

   

Milind Alvares August 27, 2009 at 12:56 pm soggysh.it

@Mitchell: I guess we all have different tastes so it’s a good thing there’s a choice (and a 30 day trial on each choice, I might add).

@Burke: It’s from http://iconpaper.org. There’s no direct link to it, so you’ll have to dig around.

   

Ken August 30, 2009 at 4:51 pm

Hi Nobody has mentioned quality and file sizes. I invite you check out my movies made with Camtasia for Mac and Snapz Pro X. They were made with Photoshop CS4 on an Eizo ColorEdge CE210W flat screen designed for graphics.
http://www.screencast.com/t/zsM0RC98CHx9
Snapz Pro was made with a record size of 1280x720 set manually on a screen size of 1680x1025. High Quality Media setting was used with Sorenson Video 3 codec – Key Frame Rate 10 – Bit Rate 6400kbits.
File Size 20.4 MB for 3 mins.49 secs

Camtasia for Mac was made at full screen (1680x1025) on the same monitor. RECORD PREFERENCES 100%. RENDER PREFERENCES – Advance Export – Export to QuickTime Movie. OPTIONS – High Quality Media setting. Sorenson Video 3 codec. Key Frame Rate 10. PRESET DIMENTION 1280x720
File Size a whopping 83.6MB for 3 mins 56 secs. I have cut this to 20 secs for you to download or view at screencast. I would like to point out that the preset size of 1280x720 was slightly smaller than the Snapz Pro 1280x720 manually set.

I use Sorenson Video 3 codec because the color of the movies match my screen and the file size is not that much bigger. I use the QuickTime .mov file format for quality. MPG4 or any of the other codec’s are not as good as the Sorenson Video 3.

I have spent many hours on Camtasia for Mac since purchasing it to try and get similar quality and file sizes to Snapz Pro X and I have not been able to achieve this. When you watch the movies you will see just how good Snapz Pro is and the files sizes are so small. I have been very loyal to Camtasia on the PC, starting with version 5 and buying version 6 but the quality aint up to Snapx Pro

KEN

   

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: