{ 28 comments… read them below or add one }

samu

I’ve tried the first three of these, plus Manifesto and a couple of others not worth mentioning. None of them, for me, comes close to Google Reader’s web interface.

   

Oskar

Thanks for the tip about Reeder, didn’t know about it.

   

David

I love Bylines, I was a big NetNewsWire user but the lack of iPhone support for a few weeks made me look elsewhere. Byline is brilliant.

   

Jeffrey Horn

Fever all the way! I swear I don’t know how I kept up with news before this app.

http://www.feedafever.com

You’ll need hosting space (I only spend pennies a day on my mine), a little bit of web know-how, and 15 minutes.

After you get everything setup, you can add an “app” by creating a Fever webclip from Safari. It’ll even show unread item counts if you enable that feature.

   

joecab

Actually NetNewsWire doesn’t have landscape in its opening screens, but it does support landscape if you follow a page link.

   

Lhasapso

I use an app called Reader (with an A), by Enormego. It’s pretty basic, but it works well, and it doesn’t require a Google Reader account.

   

Karen

I love Reeder – and I’m certainly hoping that Instapaper support will be added soon. The interface is stunning (although some of the symbols aren’t entirely intuitive at first).

   

PJ

I started with NNW but switched it to Byline because i wanted offline caching. I stuck with Byline for ages as it had great potential and was a step ahead of the rest of the competition, but updates are slow and it can be really buggy sometimes. It seems to update in one batch so if the update isn’t completed before you close the app, it defaults to what it was like before viewed (so losing all of the read/unread counts and newly added posts), the unread notification badge often isn’t there or is incorrect and the nice little animation for adding posts and flicking through subscriptions can hold up actually reading articles. The final straw was finding that the rare occurrence of headlines not matching with corresponding articles had become an epidemic (about 80% of the feeds were crossed). I’m now back to NNW 2.0 and although it isn’t perfect it is definitely better and should be great after the next update

   

dasreal

Newsstand was my reader of choice BECAUSE of the horizontal

   

dasreal

Newsstand was my reader of choice BECAUSE of the innovative horizontal newspaper view but the vocal minority has proven influential and instead of making it better, each release has seen it depreciated to become almost unsuable. The potrait view is fine if you like reading your feeds like an email but that’s not what I wanted from my newsreader :( . I like hat I can still import from opml though. All the others require googlereader now with I hate.

Fever looks good but it’s too much work setting up a server and it costs more than all the others combined.

I use NNW on the Mac but the phone client was alreays too simple to be useful.

I’ll try Reeder out now but lets hope he adds the extra feature soon (ReaditLater support is needed)

   

Patrick Murphy

does reeder display a badge beside its icon for unread articles? it looks interesting.
i have been using byline.

   

Fabien Penso

My current version of Notifications which I’ll submit on the appstore soon is way better for RSS feeds. Can’t say much for now, but you will *love* it for RSS.

   

Rizzi

@Patrick Murphy: Yes, this can be enabled in the Prefs.

   

Patrick Murphy

is reeder faster than byline in loading new feeds and all? it sounds intriguing but i just don’t know if i want to fork over the money whenever i already have paid for byline. byline seems to work fine but i guess i just need to know what’s better about reeder.
can anyone tell me?

   

Patrick Patience

@Patrick Murphy: I just did a test, and if anything, Byline loads the *slightest* bit quicker than Reeder on my 3GS. Reeder and Byline are fairly comparable, if you’re not looking for the outstanding interface I’d honestly suggest Newsstand for it’s features (though I can’t argue that Reeder has an awesome interface).

   

Patrick Murphy

ok. thanks. is newsstand pretty fast, too? i am really interested in trying something else out but am a little hesitant to spend the money. i know that byline loads the articles that don’t completely show up in google reader pretty quickly. (i can’t remember what the technical term for that is but it’s when you don’t get the full article and you have to go to the site to read all of it).

   

Daniel

Thanks for the nice quick reviews. To answer your question: I use Newsstand. It’s awesome. I’ve tried others but this blows them away. I’m not a fan of subscription based RSS because you’re always tied to the provider on the net e.g netnewswire. With Newsstand I can add my own feeds on the fly and Newsstand gets them straight from the actual websites themselves. Also, the UI is gorgeous and it has persistence, which means I can close the app or take a call and still return to where I left off.

   

Patrick Murphy

i went ahead and purchased newsstand and it seems okay at this point. i will give it more time but i don’t see much of a difference between it and byline. we will see.
thanks anyway to everyone who responded!

   

jeremy

Hi, loved the overview article, but I have a quick question.

“Although Reeder has just been released, the developer has commented that fun sharing options like email, Instapaper, and Twitter are in the works.”

I’m curious about Reeder, but the information in iTunes and on its site is very limited. There doesn’t seem to be a development blog or twitter account, so I’m curious where you heard about future updates (or any info at all! :) ). Also, in what way does it lack caching? Does that mean you need to have a network connection whenever you load the app if you want to see any previously loaded articles, or just that it doesn’t cache images/etc within articles?

Thanks!

   

Milind Alvares

@Jeremy: The developer of Reeder shared that info in our email conversations. I don’t suppose you can hold it against him (or us) if it doesn’t make it in a future update, but that’s what he said.

As for offline caching, you can read the articles, but yes, no images are cached (Maybe he was talking about full-page offline caching like Byline?). I say this as I’m usually stuck without an internet connection, and Reeder has so far shown me the core content.

   

Pascale

I was using feeds, but I am getting really p*ssed of by it’s erratic behaviour : folders missing one day, rss articles sill available after benig read some days and not others…

glad I foudn that article, I’m going to have a closer look at those. :)

   

Jorgen

I was a big fan of NetNewsWire until it reached 2. version – then it got slow and buggy. I tested some of the other rss-readers listed but ended up with my new favourite: FeedPot – strange name, but it is a simple, no-frills reader – import from Google Reader, landscape mode, decide if your want your feeds listed with newest first or last – you can manually refresh single feeds, folders or all feeds. Offline browsing – with pictures if you like. Add or delte feeds and folders directly in the app, search all news etc.
But the most important thing to me – its really fast! Free with ads or buy for only 1$

   

diane

My netnewswire links no longer work because apparently i need to change to google reader How do I take my feeds from netnewswire to google reader?
Thanks

   

Tekoo

Check out MobileRSS by NibiruTech LTD guys… so much worth it. Three versions available to suit your needs. I use the cheaper paid version and i’m so glad about it. I hate the icon but syncing is incredibly fast compared to other apps and features are all there with some extras too. Intuitive interface. There’s nothing much that can be done to make it better except for a total redesign in terms of graphics. You can even save the pictures in the feeds to your phone library. Choose to cache or not cache images. View your shared feeds…

I’m so tempted by reeder right now, but its lack of features compared to MobileRSS is telling me to wait a few weeks or so…

   

A Wang

Are there any RSS readers out there that will strip everything except for text AND have a font size option? I came from a BlackBerry using FreeRange Reader and it was excellent. I find the font size for “full article” in iPhone too small to read and strains the eye after a while.

The closest to this option is Instapaper and Read It Later, but they aren’t true RSS readers – too many extra steps needed get to a stripped text version and selectable font size option.

I have tried MobileRSS, Bylines, newsstand, Fluent, Nuage{Paper, RSS Reader, NNW, News Hour and Stanza. And even the RSS reader built into Daily Tracker. Nada!

   

Milind Alvares

@Wang: I believe the next Reeder app will allow you to set the font size for the articles view. However, the lack of contrast in the ‘theme’ might put you off, so you’re back to square one.

   

A Wang

Yup, they have released an updated version of Reeder and included a font resize option BUT it is only for the RSS article and not for the full article. Back to square one in my quest for a reader that allows font resize for the full article.

Look at the NY Times app – it allows font resize on the full article.

   

Pat

Anyone other RSS app that supports google mobilizer feature that newsstand provides ?

   

Leave a Comment

We'd love it if you would add your opinion to the article or discussion, whether positive or negative. We reserve the right to moderate comments at our discretion.

Previous post:

Next post: