Garageband in Your Pocket: Voice Band for iPhone

by Brandon Pittman on February 6, 2010

Post image for Garageband in Your Pocket: Voice Band for iPhone

I’m gonna let you folks in on a little secret. When I was a kid, I dreamed of being in a metal band. That’s about all I did. I listened to Metallica, Black Sabbath, and Pantera albums, poured over metal head mags, and dicked around for hours on end with my guitar. But alas, my dreams of playing guitar in a metal band were dashed when I couldn’t get a real metal band off the ground, and going to Japan didn’t help. Metal bands here are about 25 years behind America, and dressing up like a girl isn’t limited to Poison cover bands. So I was pleasantly surprised when I tried out Voice Band for iPhone, and rocked the shit out of my lonely one-room apartment.

To be honest, when our fearless editor asked me to review Voice Band, I took one look at its goofy UI and almost told him to stick Voice Band where the sun don’t shine. I was a little taken aback when he didn’t seem to be bothered by the idea, but he made it clear that he really wanted to hear what I had to say about Voice Band. So after choking down my “OMG HOW COULD YOU USE THIS UGLY FONT?” rage, I tried to give Voice Band a fair shake. And I’m happy to say that if you give the tech a chance, you’ll be happy as well.

Voice Band’s a really fun app. While most people will probably just use it to make goofy songs, it could also be used to whip up a draft of a song you have floating around in your head. You can lay down a bunch of tracks using rhythm and lead guitars, bass, drums, two kinds of synthesizers, organs, saxophones, and vocals. You can adjust octaves and time signatures, and when you’ve laid down all the tracks you want, you can save your “Stairway to Heaven” and email it out as an mp3 to the rest of the world can hear it. It was a little hard to get the music-making process down at first. I’m a “dun-dun-dun” guy when I’m humming, but Voice Band seems to respond best to “ba-ba-ba”. They do make mention of this in the lengthy (read: so long no one’s ever gonna read it) help section. I would’ve never figured that out if I hadn’t watched the introduction video on the app’s website. Also included is the ability to pull up any song on your iPhone to listen along to (use headphones for best results), and you can plagiarize till the cows come home. It’s really easy to make pretty decent sounding songs once you get the hang of it.

But that does not excuse its UI. It’s God awful. The icon you see on your iPhone looks like Eddie Vedder with a spray-on tan and peroxided hair. The icons for the instruments in the app were designed by Word 97 graphic designers, I believe, and for Christ’s sake, what are you doing using a cartoony font like this in 2010? Who do you think you are, Apple? It’s like Comic Sans and Marker Felt both jizzed in a Dixie cup, swirled it around, and then threw it in your face. I’m advocating the creation of a good old fashion letter-writing campaign in order to put a stop to cartoony font use. And it needs to start with Voice Band. Because I’m betting you that a bunch of design snobs are passing Voice Band up because it looks like that homely girl you took to the Fall Formal in junior high school but ditched behind the gym so you could hang out with the cool kids by the punch bowl.

Overall, the app’s abilities are impressive, and if you would like to record your musical ideas even when you don’t have access to your instruments, Voice Band makes a good musical notepad. Pick it up in the App Store for $2.99. Just don’t let its UI get in the way of what could be the start of a beautiful relationship that will ultimately end with Voice Band sleeping with your girlfriend and refusing to give you back your lovingly curated collection of signed hipster indie-band guitar picks.

Reader Comments

lin2log February 6, 2010 at 6:50 pm

Wow… can’t believe how painfully JUVENILE this bullshit site is. Not to be taken the LEAST bit serious, and just plain a WASTE OF TIME for anyone older than TWELVE and/or with an IQ >20.

Give a kid a site and he thinks he’s the coolest and funniest thing since left turning yoghurt.

Sad.

You’re smokin’ somethin’, but it sure ain’t APPLES.

   

Sayam Aggarwal February 6, 2010 at 6:59 pm cultofmac.com/author/sayam-aggarwal

Guess you had a drug overdose or something.. ;)

Milind Alvares February 6, 2010 at 7:44 pm soggysh.it

Wow! The use of CAPS LOCK does make your point so much clearer! Without it your comment would look weak and poorly thought out. But man oh man, that CAPS LOCK really adds AUTHORITY and INTELLIGENCE to your point, making it STAND OUT! Respect!

- your biggest fan

lin2log February 6, 2010 at 7:15 pm

*applause*… what an amazingly CLEVER (i.e. utterly nonsensical) retort!!

Thanks for making my point that much more valid (and by the looks of it, expanding it’s application to further sites… yours).

   

Sayam Aggarwal February 6, 2010 at 7:18 pm cultofmac.com/author/sayam-aggarwal

Guess we all know that who’s talking non-sense here.

lin2log February 6, 2010 at 7:35 pm

*heightened-applause*
It’s “nonsense” actually. Try a basic spelling class sometime.

   

Sayam Aggarwal February 6, 2010 at 7:41 pm cultofmac.com/author/sayam-aggarwal

After you go for a mental checkup…

Chris February 6, 2010 at 10:57 pm

Good grief, can’t we review an app without profanity and vulgarity? “Jizzed in a cup?” Seriously? Is this Smoking Apple’s new gimmick - juvenile and gratuitous? And then you get into a verbal slugfest (and not a witty one) with one of your readers?

Consider me unsubscribed. Good luck with you Howard Stern approach to blogging. Absurd.

   

lin2log February 6, 2010 at 11:21 pm

LOL… what a pathetic Kindergarden!! Thank you Chris for making that (obvious) point (SA just lost their only other NON-single-digit-IQ reader) and mostly Brandon Tardman for reminding me of one of the main reasons why americans are such a joke and such juvenile fucktards globally speaking: their “education”. Bet you’ll be telling that story even after you flunked 9th grade for the 3rd time, huh?… it’s so FUUUU-NNY!

*unsubscribe*

   

lin2log February 6, 2010 at 11:24 pm

ooooooh…. CENSORSHIP!!

Try it on yourself and your primordial-level posts sometime.

   

Pustoolio February 7, 2010 at 3:03 am

Font Bukake? You sir are ahead of your time. Congrats!

   

Pustoolio February 7, 2010 at 3:05 am

@lin2log - I think you vastly overrate the digital length of your IQ member.

   

Robin Stark February 7, 2010 at 6:36 pm webflunky.com

@lin2log, even though he/she is unsubscribed: you might want to reconsider slamming the American education with a post littered with poor grammar and punctuation and capitalization errors, e.g., commas missing in “Thank you, Chris, for …”; the word American should be capitalized; the period goes inside the closing quotation mark in “education.”

There are others errors, of course, but I really wanted to talk about the font used in Voice Band for iPhone. I can see Brandon’s point about the font possibly making design elitists want to run in the other direction. On the other hand, the cartoony nature of it makes it seem more accessible to me, and I would be more inclined to want to use it with this look than if it contained a lot of grey, black, and silver sliders and knobs. Maybe the developer should offer a couple of different skins for this app.

   

Milind Alvares February 8, 2010 at 2:15 am soggysh.it

Even I found the UI to be quite pleasing. The cartoony font went well with the hand drawn knobs and such. My only complaint, is that it doesn’t merge very well with the standard tab bar, which could have used some work.

Patrick Patience February 8, 2010 at 4:01 am twitter.com/PatrickPatience

@Milind: Yes, yes! Damn custom UI’s with standard tab bar! Momento did it right - http://cld.ly/661b7d

lin2log February 7, 2010 at 7:39 pm

@Robin
Well gee, all that blather would in fact be of minimal value, if one were, as American’s always do, to assume I myself were in fact American, huh?? But, quite fortunately, I’m NOT, thank god. I’m from a non-english-language country that YOU (typically) wouldn’t even be able to point to on a map (as with ANY other country outside the US)… and you only WISH you could speak ANY other language even HALF as well as I speak (or WRITE for that matter) my FOUR… but, your little american ivory tower life with no real educational system wouldn’t allow for that, would it?

You’re to be pitied.

   

chrisherbert1 February 7, 2010 at 9:25 pm

What a fun review and for such serious complaining! It’s a free world and people can say what they want but if you have a problem with how reviews are presented, please read reviews elsewhere or go write your own. The SA crew does a great job with this site and if you really knew the people who do this, you wouldn’t complain so much. They’re honest and entertaining. That is all, so now you can follow up and bash my commenting style!

   

robinson February 7, 2010 at 10:02 pm

Glad for the review, interesting material, but lose the 4-letter words and crudity!

   

Milind Alvares February 8, 2010 at 2:18 am soggysh.it

Feedback received. I’ll keep Brandon under control next time.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: