Someone over at Techradar has posted a piece [link] on how iTunes has become a bloated piece of crap, and offered beautiful suggestions on how Apple could change iTunes. From what it looks like however, the author is either a Windows user or has just switched over. Let’s go over the points he makes.
1. Clean up the interface
What’s wrong with the iTunes interface? The author clearly wants only the list view, and if that’s the case, use the list view! No one is forcing anyone to use the Grid view or Coverflow. Both may be gimicky, but they work just fine for the rest of us.
I will however say that the Grid view does bring an inconsistent UI into the application, which Apple seems to be just testing out. In the next version a cleanup of the grid view would be appreciated.
2. Bar the Genius
Okay hold of a minute. The main feature of genius is playlist generation, and one that works fine. The tracks that are recommended are not necessarily those available in the store as it uses user data to generate playlists. Apple is not making any money out of Genius playlist feature. The Genius feature is also a fantastic addition for the iPhone/iPod and is something I use on a daily basis.
The Genius Sidebar on the other hand is just the rebranded mini-store and can be left out of this discussion.
3. Better file handling
While we would all like to play our pirated content in iTunes, Apple is not going to let that happen because of the record deals. So hopes of iTunes being able to play x264 and all that jazz isn’t going to get them to allow that media. Deal with it.
The author then wants iTunes to seamlessly convert video files as and when needed while syncing an iPod or iPhone instead of you having to manually convert those files (resulting in two of the same on your hard drive). This is insane! A single 200MB video file takes 15 minutes to convert! Imagine the hue and cry that will follow when people find their iPhone takes six days to sync up!
For those confused, to convert a video file (say a HD quicktime video) to iPhone format, just right-click and select “Convert for iPhone”. This creates a new file in your library leaving the original one as it is.
4. Better handling of Multiple libraries
This is absolutely rubbish. Most users are content with a single library. And for those who want a second one, hold down the option key at startup! How much simpler can it get? The author is also aware that there are plugins for this purpose at dough’s scripts. Since this is a more advanced feature, script hunting is fair game.
5. Better file tracking
In all my years of using iTunes with the “manage my music folder” checked, I have never faced a problem of file tracking. This is only two Windows geeks who prefer to manage their music in custom folders and then end up crying about it on the web.
And, on the Mac there’s no such thing as losing a file. iTunes will keep a track of your file if you move it or even change its name. Unfortunately, Windows is a little backward in technology hence there is no way to do this.
6. Better database handling
Why do we have to care? iTunes is always running on my Mac, and it hardly uses 200MB to do the same. Even the startup, with my 8000 song library is very fast. I wouldn’t care if iTunes used a MS Word document as a database.
7. Better codec support
The author suggests iTunes should support WMV. Nuff said.
8. Multi-room support
The Airport Express, AppleTV and iPhone are more than capable tools at extending your iTunes library outside of the computer den.
9. Cheaper iTunes Store
How does this apply to iTunes? In any case, 256kbps tracks are more than enough for anyone who listens to music. Simply making uninterested users download heavy CD-quality tracks does not make good sense. And at $1 per song, Apple has proven that it is a very good business model. Case to point: 5 billion songs sold already.
10. iTunes Pro
This I will partially agree with. Just as iPhoto has Aperture, and iMovie has Final Cut, iTunes should have a pro version. Something that is totally detatched from the free version of iTunes (no ads for the pro version please!), that has a lot of powerful features and expandability for those who want a little more than the basic version. This will of course never happen as there is no way Steve Jobs will allow a pro version of iTunes to be released.
So what does Apple need to change then?
For one, it needs to improve the code. Snow Leopard is going through the shredder, and so should iTunes. Especially the Windows version (have you used iTunes on Windows lately?). Making iTunes blazing fast, optimised from the ground up, will make this application the more preferred music player on Windows, as it is on the Mac.
I’d also like to see some improvements in the interface of the iTunes store. Tabbed browsing would be nice, wish lists, and a more responsive search (Store > Search…) feature.
Any gripes with iTunes? Share them in the comments.